Under $25

Small gifts, useful finds and easy add-ons under $25.

New here? Take 10% off $50+ with code WELCOME10 · Fast checkout with Shop Pay
Skip to results list
457 items

Filter

  • Bible Activity Book: Journey to the Promised Land

    Bible Activity Book: Journey to the Promised Land

    Bible Activity Book: Journey to the Promised Land
    $5.99
  • Bible Activity Book: Creation to Babel

    Bible Activity Book: Creation to Babel

    Bible Activity Book: Creation to Babel
    $5.99
  • Turkey Gravy Beans & Rolls Shirt – Funny Thanksgiving Casserole Tee

    Turkey Gravy Beans & Rolls Shirt – Funny Thanksgiving Casserole Tee

    Turkey Gravy Beans & Rolls Shirt – Funny Thanksgiving Casserole Tee
    From $22.95
  • Fall the Things Cotton Tea Towel

    Fall the Things Cotton Tea Towel

    Fall the Things Cotton Tea Towel
    $13.99
  • Pumpkin Pie Spice

    Pumpkin Pie Spice

    Pumpkin Pie Spice
    From $5.99
  • Psychocandy - Roasted Pumpkin Caramel Rooibos Tea (Caffeine Free)

    Psychocandy - Roasted Pumpkin Caramel Rooibos Tea (Caffeine Free)

    Psychocandy - Roasted Pumpkin Caramel Rooibos Tea (Caffeine Free)
    From $5.99
  • Ginger Pumpkin Air + Fabric Spray

    Ginger Pumpkin Air + Fabric Spray

    Ginger Pumpkin Air + Fabric Spray
    $17.99
  • Pumpkin Spice Leggings

    Pumpkin Spice Leggings

    Pumpkin Spice Leggings
    $12.00
  • Don't Get Your Tinsel in a Tangle Keychain

    Don't Get Your Tinsel in a Tangle Keychain

    Don't Get Your Tinsel in a Tangle Keychain
    $10.99
  • Merry Christmas Charm Keychain

    Merry Christmas Charm Keychain

    Merry Christmas Charm Keychain
    $13.99
  • 2026 Annual Ornament - Cozy Christmas Hearth (Bronze)

    2026 Annual Ornament- Cozy Christmas Hearth (Bronze)

    2026 Annual Ornament- Cozy Christmas Hearth (Bronze)
    $21.99
  • Ho Ho Ho Santa Charm Keychain

    Ho Ho Ho Santa Charm Keychain

    Ho Ho Ho Santa Charm Keychain
    $10.99
  • Women's Chunky Heart Stone Cluster Toggle Pendant Statement Necklace

    Women's Chunky Heart Stone Cluster Toggle Pendant Statement Necklace

    Women's Chunky Heart Stone Cluster Toggle Pendant Statement Necklace
    $24.99
  • Women's Starfish Charm Pendant Necklace

    Women's Starfish Charm Pendant Necklace

    Women's Starfish Charm Pendant Necklace
    $19.99
  • My First Beignet Organic Cotton Baby Bib

    My First Beignet Organic Cotton Baby Bib

    My First Beignet Organic Cotton Baby Bib
    $12.00
  • My First King Cake Organic Cotton Baby Bib

    My First King Cake Organic Cotton Baby Bib

    My First King Cake Organic Cotton Baby Bib
    $12.00
  • Western Bandana Bibs Collection

    Western Bandana Bibs Collection

    Western Bandana Bibs Collection
    $18.99
  • Beware Mama Bear 20 oz Tumbler | Red

    Beware Mama Bear 20 oz Tumbler | Red

    Beware Mama Bear 20 oz Tumbler | Red
    $23.99
  • Tiny Tracker Bandana Bibs Collection

    Tiny Tracker Bandana Bibs Collection

    Tiny Tracker Bandana Bibs Collection
    $18.99
  • Knit Baby Pom Beanie in Sage Green

    Knit Baby Pom Beanie in Sage Green

    Knit Baby Pom Beanie in Sage Green
    $22.00
  • What If I'm Not Silly Enough Can Cooler

    What If I'm Not Silly Enough Can Cooler

    What If I'm Not Silly Enough Can Cooler
    $6.99
  • Muslin Swaddle Blankets

    Muslin Swaddle Blankets

    Muslin Swaddle Blankets
    $16.99
  • Parker Clear Stadium Bag

    Parker Clear Stadium Bag

    Parker Clear Stadium Bag
    $22.79
  • Juni Clear Stadium Sling Crossbody Belt Bum Fanny Waist Bag

    Juni Clear Stadium Sling Crossbody Belt Bum Fanny Waist Bag

    Juni Clear Stadium Sling Crossbody Belt Bum Fanny Waist Bag
    $19.19